Table of contents
Which is better: A Security Guard or a Surveillance System for Protecting Your Business?
When it comes to business security services, owners must decide between commercial security guard services and surveillance systems for businesses. Both are important but the effectiveness of the one depends on factors such as crime deterrence, emergency response, and cost efficiency. This detailed comparison will help you choose the better service for your business if you are wondering which one is better.
Why Security Guards Offer Better Protection Than CCTV?
The security guard vs. CCTV effectiveness debate often boils down to one major point: Real Time Response. A surveillance camera can record a crime but it can’t stop it in progress. Commercial security guard services offer human intervention, something a camera simply can’t provide. Security guards are highly trained professionals who are able to:
1. Identifying threats before they escalate
2. Physically intervening during security breaches
3. Assisting employees and customers in emergency situations
4. Preventing unauthorised entry by managing access control
A Canadian security industry report states that businesses that rely on on-site security personnel have 30% less theft and vandalism than those that only rely on video surveillance monitoring. This statistic shows how important human presence is in the process of security risk management for companies.
The Limitations of Surveillance Systems for Businesses
Although the surveillance technology for businesses has come a long way, it still has some weaknesses. Surveillance cameras are ideal for monitoring and documenting activities. However, they are not as effective in preventing activities.
Even the most advanced surveillance systems cannot:
1. Stop an active break-in
2. Respond to threats in real-time
3. Help employees or customers in emergencies
4. Be able to adjust to unexpected security threats without human input
That is why businesses in high risk areas or industries that require immediate security response should consider security guard patrol services instead of relying solely on cameras.
Security Guards: How They Provide Proactive Prevention, Not Just Reaction
Canada's Security Services market has grown to $9.0 billion in 2023 with an annual growth of 4.7%, influenced by the expanding demand for commercial security guard services from corporate and government customers. This growth is a primary reason why companies are switching to security guards, not merely for emergency response but also for proactive prevention.
Threat Detection and Crime Prevention
Surveillance systems for businesses, which record incidents as they occur, do not actively stop crimes. However, commercial security guard services go beyond just reacting to security threats. They prevent them before they occur. Human security professionals are trained to prevent, not to damage control. They are trained to recognise suspicious behaviour, and intervene before an incident escalates. For instance, security guards in a shopping mall don’t wait for theft to occur. They observe body language, look for threats, and talk to people who seem suspicious. Their proactive approach stops many security incidents from becoming serious problems.
Making Informed Decisions
A real time threat response is not just about responding to crimes in progress. It’s about having trained professionals who know how to assess the risks, how to handle tense situations, and how to make judgement calls that technology cannot. The ability to think on their feet and make informed decisions based on experience and training is crucial for businesses to manage security risk.
Why Human Judgement in Security Cannot be Replaced
The most advanced surveillance system functionalities rely on programming and AI detection, but do not have human reasoning. Unusual movement detected by a security camera cannot be assessed for intent. A commercial security guard knows the difference between the employee who stays late to finish work and the intruder who is trying to break in.
False Alarms and Ineffective Alerts
False alarms are one of the biggest weaknesses of video surveillance monitoring. Alerts triggered by motion sensors may be for harmless activities that waste time and resources. However, security guards evaluate the situation in real world context and experience.
Incident Documentation
Surveillance cameras only document what happens in emergency situations such as fires, medical incidents, or violent altercations. Security guard patrol services make sure someone is around to lead evacuations, administer first aid, and call for emergency services right away.
What Businesses Benefit More from Security Guards?
Certain industries demand real-time threat response, which only commercial security guard services can provide. The businesses that should pay much attention to security guards are:
1. Retail Stores Security Services: To prevent shoplifting and handle aggressive customers
2. Banks & Financial Institutions: To manage access and deter armed robberies
3. Hospitals & Healthcare Facilities: To assist patients, control visitor access, and de-escalate conflicts
4. Hotels & Resorts: To provide guest safety and control unauthorized entries
5. Construction Sites Security: To monitor expensive equipment and prevent unauthorized entry at night
These businesses require on-site security personnel because of the high risk of physical confrontations, theft, or emergencies. Surveillance systems alone won’t be enough to ensure safety.
When Should a Business Use Surveillance Systems Instead?
Surveillance systems for businesses may be a cost effective choice for businesses with minimal security threats. Some businesses that might be better off with cameras than security guards are:
1. Office Spaces Security – For monitoring employee activity and controlling access
2. Warehouses & Storage Facilities Security – For remote monitoring of inventory
3. Parking Lots and Garages Security – For recording suspicious activity and vehicle damage incidents
4. Low Crime Area Businesses – where security risks are minimal and deterrence is not a major concern
If budget is a major consideration, then a surveillance system could be a viable option, but it still lacks the deterrence and real time threat response that guards provide.
CCTV vs Security Guard: Cost Comparison
Companies compare the cost of hiring security guards to the cost of installing cameras. Surveillance systems have upfront costs, while security guards need ongoing wages. Nevertheless, when one considers the long term benefits of hiring security guards, the cost is outweighed by the benefits.
1. Financial losses that businesses suffer from theft and vandalism
2. How security breaches could have been prevented had they been intervened upon immediately.
3. Added responsibility of monitoring camera feeds, which still require human supervision
The question of CCTV vs. security guard effectiveness isn’t just about cost, it’s about the value of real time action. Security guards are actively preventing crimes from happening, while cameras can only provide footage.
The Best Business Security Strategy: Combining Both Guards and Surveillance
For optimal security, the best approach is a combination of commercial security guard services and surveillance technology for businesses. Guard cameras prevent incidents in real time, and cameras provide evidence. Those who implement both experience higher crime deterrence, better security management, and safer employees and customers.
For the Best Commercial Security Services, choose G Force Security.
If you’re looking for best business security practices, G Force Security offers customized commercial property safety measures. We combine highly trained security guards with the latest surveillance technologies. Having years of experience in security risk management for businesses, we offer real time threat response that cameras can’t offer.
FAQ's
Security guards can act immediately and deal with incidents as they happen, whereas cameras only record events.
No. Cameras are valuable, but they can’t prevent crimes or respond to security threats.
No matter how advanced your cameras are, they can’t stop an emergency or stop a criminal.
Security guards actively prevent and respond to threats in real time, while cameras provide recorded evidence.
By keeping a strong presence, patrolling the area, controlling access, and intervening in suspicious situations.
Assess your risk level, industry needs, and budget to determine whether commercial security guard services or surveillance systems for businesses are the best fit.
Unlock the Buzz! Click for breaking news, exclusives, and pure inspiration.
Other Blogs
- G Force Security
Table of contents Protecting your commercial building is more than simply locking doors. It’s about having the proper commercial building
- G Force Security
Table of contents Which is better: A Security Guard or a Surveillance System for Protecting Your Business? When it comes
- G Force Security
Table of contents Every year, Canadian companies lose about $10 billion to crimes that occur at work, such as theft,
- G Force Security
Table of contents Retail companies now struggle to keep their products safe and make enough money. Shoplifting and employee theft
- G Force Security
Table of contents Retail companies now struggle to keep their products safe and make enough money. Shoplifting and employee theft
- G Force Security
Table of contents As the world becomes more dynamic and complex, Security Services in Canada must respond to modern threats
